Why Motivating Students Backfires
Most people believe that the only way to motivate students is with rewards and punishments. Rewards such as good grades and eventually a middle class life await those who can meet the standards of the institution.
Recent research demonstrates that not only do extrinsic motivators (rewards and punishments) not work on tasks that require creativity, complex problem solving, or other higher order skills, they actually decrease performance.
To increase performance, teachers need to create an environment that fosters intrinsic motivation, turning most traditional classroom practice and management upside down.
The bad news is that research shows these types of motivators tend to backfire in important ways. If you are rewarding students for rote work that doesn’t require creativity or problem solving, rewards and punishments work quite well. However, for work that requires higher order skills, it’s a different story.
Research shows that rewards work in highly counterintuitive ways. In fact:
- Rewards don’t make us happy – even lottery winners return to their previous level of happiness after about three months
- Rewards can decrease performance
- Rewards can actually make us stop enjoying things we love, as when a student who loves to read who is given a reward for every book completed then starts focusing on the reward and loses the joy he or she once had in reading for its own sake.
It is almost impossible to imagine motivating students without rewards, but it is entirely possible. It simply requires activating their intrinsic motivation.
Rarely do students exhibit that kind of passion about their schoolwork, but when they do it’s magical. It happens in classrooms where students see their work as truly meaningful and pedagogical approaches are used that help ignite intrinsic motivation.
In order for intrinsic motivation to thrive, there need to be three elements in place:
- Autonomy – students have choice in what they do, how they do it, and when they do it
- Mastery – students learn deeply about things they see as valuable
- Meaning – students find the work relevant and authentic